Technische Universität Braunschweig
  • Study & Teaching
    • Beginning your Studies
      • Prospective Students
      • Degree Programmes
      • Application
      • Fit4TU
      • Why Braunschweig?
    • During your Studies
      • Fresher's Hub
      • Term Dates
      • Courses
      • Practical Information
      • Beratungsnavi
      • Additional Qualifications
      • Financing and Costs
      • Special Circumstances
      • Health and Well-being
      • Campus life
    • At the End of your Studies
      • Discontinuation and Credentials Certification
      • After graduation
      • Alumni
    • For Teaching Staff
      • Strategy, Offers and Information
      • Learning Management System Stud.IP
    • Contact
      • Study Service Centre
      • Academic Advice Service
      • Student Office
      • Career Service
  • Research
    • Research Profile
      • Core Research Areas
      • Clusters of Excellence at TU Braunschweig
      • Research Projects
      • Research Centres
      • Professors‘ Research Profiles
    • Early Career Researchers
      • Support in the early stages of an academic career
      • PhD-Students
      • Junior research group leaders
      • Junior Professorship and Tenure-Track
      • Habilitation
      • Service Offers for Scientists
    • Research Data & Transparency
      • Transparency in Research
      • Research Data
      • Open Access Strategy
      • Digital Research Announcement
    • Research Funding
      • Research Funding Network
      • Research funding
    • Contact
      • Research Services
      • Academy for Graduates
  • International
    • International Students
      • Why Braunschweig?
      • Degree seeking students
      • Exchange Studies
      • TU Braunschweig Summer School
      • Refugees
      • International Student Support
      • International Career Service
    • Going Abroad
      • Studying abroad
      • Internships abroad
      • Teaching and research abroad
      • Working abroad
    • International Researchers
      • Welcome Support for International Researchers
      • Service for Host Institutes
    • Language and intercultural competence training
      • Learning German
      • Learning Foreign Languages
      • Intercultural Communication
    • International Profile
      • Internationalisation
      • International Cooperations
      • Strategic partnerships
      • International networks
    • International House
      • About us
      • Contact & Office Hours
      • News and Events
      • International Days
      • 5th Student Conference: Internationalisation of Higher Education
      • Newsletter, Podcast & Videos
      • Job Advertisements
  • TU Braunschweig
    • Our Profile
      • Aims & Values
      • Regulations and Guidelines
      • Alliances & Partners
      • The University Development Initiative 2030
      • Facts & Figures
      • Our History
    • Career
      • Working at TU Braunschweig
      • Vacancies
    • Economy & Business
      • Entrepreneurship
      • Friends & Supporters
    • General Public
      • Check-in for Students
      • CampusXperience
      • The Student House
      • Access to the University Library
    • Media Services
      • Communications and Press Service
      • Services for media
      • Film and photo permits
      • Advices for scientists
      • Topics and stories
    • Contact
      • General Contact
      • Getting here
  • Organisation
    • Presidency & Administration
      • Executive Board
      • Designated Offices
      • Administration
      • Committees
    • Faculties
      • Carl-Friedrich-Gauß-Fakultät
      • Faculty of Life Sciences
      • Faculty of Architecture, Civil Engineering and Environmental Sciences
      • Faculty of Mechanical Engineering
      • Faculty of Electrical Engineering, Information Technology, Physics
      • Faculty of Humanities and Education
    • Institutes
      • Institutes from A to Z
    • Facilities
      • University Library
      • Gauß-IT-Zentrum
      • Professional and Personnel Development
      • International House
      • The Project House of the TU Braunschweig
      • Transfer Service
      • University Sports Center
      • Facilities from A to Z
    • Equal Opportunity Office
      • Equal Opportunity Office
      • Family
      • Diversity for Students
  • Search
  • Quicklinks
    • People Search
    • Webmail
    • cloud.TU Braunschweig
    • Messenger
    • Cafeteria
    • Courses
    • Stud.IP
    • Library Catalogue
    • IT Services
    • Information Portal (employees)
    • Link Collection
    • DE
    • EN
    • Instagram
    • YouTube
    • LinkedIn
    • Mastodon
    • Bluesky
Menu
  • Organisation
  • Faculties
  • Faculty of Mechanical Engineering
  • Institutes
  • Institute of Flight Guidance
  • Research
  • Projects
Logo Institut für Flugführung der TU Braunschweig
C2Land
  • Projects
    • AeroInspekt
    • AISA
    • C2Land
    • 3D BridgeInspect
    • OpAL
    • MesSBAR
    • SE²A - ARGO
    • SE²A - ARGO²
    • SE²A - EverScale
    • ← Back

C2Land

Logo C2Land

Optically aided autonomous landing of eVTOLs and fixed-wing aircraft

The landing phase is a challenging phase of flight, which requires high precision and reliable navigation solutions. Nevertheless, the desire for increasing automation further increases the demands on the technical systems. The goal of C2Land is to optically detect the landing site and utilize it to determine the relative position of the aircraft in order to perform independent and accurate on-board integrity monitoring of a satellite-based navigation system without additional ground infrastructure, especially at low altitudes. Based on this, high-precision flight guidance and control systems can enable autonomous landings until touchdown.

 

Autonomous landing of eVTOLs

In the current project phase, an optical localization system for eVTOLs is being developed. The information-rich visual environment is captured by several cameras in the visible and near-infrared range. From this, various features of the vertipad are detected using computer vision and artificial intelligence methods. Typical landing field features such as lines, circles and letters are used and investigated, as well as QR code like ArUco-markers. Geometric relationships are then exploited to perform accurate self-localization.

Computer Vision System detects features of the vertipads and calculates a position: left rectangular vertipad, right circular vertipad with ArUco-markers
Computer Vision System detects features of the vertipads and calculates a position

While satellite-based navigation systems generally achieve sufficient accuracy to perform precise landings, the validity of the position solution cannot be verified without additional complex ground infrastructure. Thus, with current (SBAS) procedures aircraft can only be guided to a minimum altitude of about 60 meters (200 ft). With the independent optical solution, the integrity of the entire localization solution can be checked autonomously and continuously. In this way, the confidence in the overall solution can be increased to the point where it can be used until touchdown. Thereby, the integrity requirements are determined dynamically in a top-down approach and in a technology-independent holistic concept. The so-called Total Capability Approach (TCA) considers the available error budget across all systems and enables better utilization of the same throughout the individual systems while maintaining the same level of security.

In a further step, the Institute of Flight System Dynamics at the Technical University of Munich takes the dynamic properties of the complex and novel aircraft into account when generating approach trajectories. Using a specialized flight controller, control commands can be sent to the aircraft to perform autonomous landings. To ensure safety between traffic participants during landing, f.u.n.k.e Avionics GmbH is developing a transponder-based anti-collision system and provides avionics components for the exchange, recording and telemetric transmission of system data.

In collaboration with a german air taxi company, the C2Land system will be installed in an eVTOL as an experimental vehicle and will be further developed and validated in several test campaigns. At the end of the project duration, a fully automated landing of this aircraft without additional ground infrastructure shall be demonstrated.

eVTOL equipped with C2Land-system on vertipad
eVTOL equipped with C2Land-system on vertipad
Autonomous landing of fixed-wing aircraft
Logo C2Land

Until now in regular operations, fully automatic landings for fixed-wing aircraft have also only been carried out in poor visibility conditions and with the use of costly ground infrastructure. In order to exploit the potential of satellite-based inertial navigation (GNSS/INS) for landing independent of further infrastructure, an optical positioning solution for on-board autonomous independent integrity monitoring was developed.

Using cameras operating in the visible and infrared range and specially developed image processing algorithms, the runway is optically detected and the relative position of the aircraft is determined. With the help of the precise and reliable navigation solution, a specialized control system can guide the approach and safely touch down on the centerline. Together with the Technical University of Munich and with the aircraft manufacturer Diamond Aircraft Industries GmbH (DAI), it was possible to demonstrate a fully automatic landing with optical-assisted GNSS/INS navigation for the first time.

Video C2Land
Your browser does not support the video tag.

The optical localization and guidance system is now being expanded to include other flight phases, such as taxi, takeoff and cruise, and the range of applications is being extended to include night operations, among other things. New developments in the field of computer vision and neural networks are constantly being investigated and the system optimized.

Photographs of the optical-supported navigation system: on the left side in the visible area and on the right side in the infrared area.
Photographs of the optical-supported navigation system: on the left side in the visible area and on the right side in the infrared area.
Fly-by-Wire research aircraft DA42 of the TU München during an automatic landing in Wiener Neustadt
Fly-by-Wire research aircraft DA42 of the TU München during an automatic landing in Wiener Neustadt
Area of Expertise Computer Vision

The Institute of Flight Guidance has extensive experience in the development and application of image processing algorithms in the aviation domain. Both, feature-based methods and machine learning methods are used in multi-stage and intelligently coupled algorithms. Algorithms are preferably investigated and used which, according to the current standard, make an aviation certification of the system possible.

Steps for runway detection
Steps for runway detection

For runway detection, the image is first converted into a gray-scale image with a defined depth. Special nonlinear methods ensure minimal loss of information, in particular in the case of infrared images. The image is then binarized, for example using the Otsu method. Edges or contours are extracted using Canny Edge Detection, among other methods. Straight lines are filtered. Finally, special filter criteria identify the left and right runway boundaries, the threshold and centerline. These elements can be identified much more robustly at long distances than corner points or other features. By exploiting the relationships of projective geometry, the own position in relation to the runway can be determined. This approach is supported by feature trackers and optical flow algorithms that can compensate for a momentary loss of runway visibility. Additionally, SLAM techniques are also being investigated to further enhance situational awareness. Filtering and fusion algorithms produce a joint robust position solution.

Accuracy of the optical position solution for multiple approaches
Accuracy of the optical position solution for multiple approaches

The existing data recording system and algorithms are also ideal for collecting training and validation data for machine learning. Deep neural networks (DNNs) have already been successfully trained for runway detection.

For air taxis the landing site is not yet fully defined, but will be similar to those of helicopters. In principle, the existing procedures can be used for recognition with minor modifications. Markers can be filtered by width and color. Since corner points are easily recognizable, a position can be calculated by setting up the Perspective-n-Point (PnP) problem and a bundle adjustment. If QR code like ArUco markers are also used, confidence in correct detection can be further increased by reading the binary code. Circular landing sites can be localized by geometric circle-ellipse relations.

Development is supported by suitable libraries and frameworks such as OpenCV and TensorFlow. We are constantly investigating new methods and appreciate participation in the context of student assignments and student assistantships.


Publications and Media Coverage

Media
  • TU Braunschweig Magazin: Safe landings without navigation aids on the ground (2019)

  • TU Braunschweig Magazin: Augen für das Lufttaxi (2020)

  • TU Munich Press Release: „Eyes“ for the autopilot (2019)

  • heise.de: C2Land: Autonomes Landesystem für Flugzeuge erfolgreich getestet (2019)

  • Aerokurier Ausgabe 02/2020: Automatisch landen mit C2Land (2020)

Pubikationen
  • Dekiert, Andreas & Hübner, Finn & Scholz, Lukas & Bestmann, Ulf. (2022). Nonlinear Temperature Mapping for Infrared-Based Landing Site Detection. 10.1109/DASC55683.2022.9925755.

  • Scholz, Lukas & Dekiert, Andreas & Hübner, Finn & Bestmann, Ulf. (2022). Concept for Sensor and Processing Equipment for Optical Navigation of VTOL during Approach and Landing. 10.1109/DASC55683.2022.9925802.

  • Hübner, Finn & Wolkow, Stephan & Dekiert, Andreas & Angermann, Maik & Bestmann, Ulf. (2020). Assessment of Optical Markers for On-Board Autonomous Localization of eVTOLs during Landing. ICRAT 2020.

  • Hecker, Peter & Angermann, Maik & Bestmann, Ulf & Dekiert, Andreas & Wolkow, Stephan. (2019). Optical Aircraft Positioning for Monitoring of the Integrated Navigation System during Landing Approach. Gyroscopy and Navigation. 10. 216-230. 10.1134/S2075108719040084.

  • Angermann, Maik & Wolkow, Stephan & Dekiert, Andreas & Bestmann, Ulf & Hecker, Peter. (2019). Linear Blend: Data Fusion in the Image Domain for Image-based Aircraft Positioning during Landing Approach. Proceedings of the ION 2019 Pacific PNT Meeting. 752-766. 10.33012/2019.16836.

  • Wolkow, Stephan & Angermann, Maik & Dekiert, Andreas & Bestmann, Ulf. (2019). Model-based Threshold and Centerline Detection for Aircraft Positioning during Landing Approach. Proceedings of the ION 2019 Pacific PNT Meeting. 767-776. 10.33012/2019.16787.

  • Angermann, Maik & Wolkow, Stephan & Dekiert, Andreas & Bestmann, Ulf & Hecker, Peter. (2019). Fusion of Dual Optical Position Solutions for Augmentation of GNSS-based Aircraft Landing Systems. Proceedings of the 2019 International Technical Meeting of The Institute of Navigation. 283-295. 10.33012/2019.16694.

  • Wolkow, Stephan & Schwithal, Alexander & Angermann, Maik & Dekiert, Andreas & Bestmann, Ulf. (2019). Accuracy and Availability of an Optical Positioning System for Aircraft Landing. 884-895. 10.33012/2019.16732.

  • Dekiert, Andreas & Wolkow, Stephan & Angermann, Maik & Bestmann, Ulf & Hecker, Peter. (2019). Advantages and Challenges of using Infrared Cameras for Relative Positioning during Landing. Proceedings of the 2019 International Technical Meeting of The Institute of Navigation. 896-908. 10.33012/2019.16733.

  • Schwithal, A. & Tonhauser, C. & Wolkow, Stephan & Angermann, Maik & Hecker, Peter & Mumm, N. & Holzapfel, Florian. (2017). Integrity monitoring in GNSS/INS systems by optical augmentation. 2017 DGON Inertial Sensors and Systems (ISS).  1-22. 10.1109/InertialSensors.2017.8171506.

Logo BMWK
Logo FSD
Logo TUM
Project C2Land Phase C2
  Total Capability Approach zur hochgenauen und sicheren Ortung und Bahnführung ohne bodenseitige Infrastruktur am Beispiel eines automatischen Landesystems
Funding Period October 2020 - October 2023
Cooperation Partners Institut für Flugführung (IFF)
  TU München – Institut für Flugsystemdynamik (FSD)
  f.u.n.k.e. AVIONICS GmbH
Funding Institution BMWK
Funding Code 50NA2003
Contact Finn Hübner (IFF)
Photo credits on this page

For All Visitors

Vacancies of TU Braunschweig
Career Service' Job Exchange 
Merchandising

For Students

Term Dates
Courses
Degree Programmes
Information for Freshman
TUCard

Internal Tools

Glossary (GER-EN)
Change your Personal Data

Contact

Technische Universität Braunschweig
Universitätsplatz 2
38106 Braunschweig

P. O. Box: 38092 Braunschweig
GERMANY

Phone: +49 (0) 531 391-0

Getting here

© Technische Universität Braunschweig
Legal Notice Privacy Accessibility

TU Braunschweig uses the software Matomo for anonymised web analysis. The data serve to optimise the web offer.
You can find more information in our data protection declaration.